10 FOGHORN vices including non-contiguous routes (think Alaska and Hawai‘i). The bulk of the passenger vessel industry, including sightseeing companies, dinner cruise operators, whale-watching boats, inner-harbor water taxis, and many inland ferry systems, sat outside the CCF’s reach. This changed in December 2022. The National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023 removed the geographic trading restrictions that had shaped CCF eligibility for more than fifty years and opened the program to all U.S.-built vessels engaged in domestic or foreign commerce. PVA spent years making the case that passenger vessel operators are capital-intensive businesses, build in American yards, operate under American law, em- ploy American crews, and are exactly the type of domestic maritime operators the program should support. An operator enters a formal agreement with MARAD, designates an eligible vessel or vessel project, and deposits eligible income into a dedicated account at an FDIC-in- sured or SIPC-member depository. Those deposits are excluded from taxable income in the year they are made, and earnings on the fund accumulate tax deferred. When the operator later withdraws the money for a qualified purpose, the withdrawal does not create a taxable event. It reduces the tax basis of the new vessel, spreading the tax impact over the life of the asset rather than forcing the op- erator to build with after-tax dollars upfront. The easiest way to think about it is as a maritime version of a tradition- al IRA. Operators accumulate capital with pre-tax dollars instead of after-tax dollars, and a dollar sheltered today and compounded over five, ten, or fifteen years does more work than a dollar already clipped by taxes before it ever reaches the vessel replacement account. As of the end of 2023, 136 participants held approximately $2.6 billion on deposit in CCF accounts. A NOTE ON PRE-2022 ELIGIBILITY Before the 2022 amendment, eligibility was tied to specific qualifying trades: foreign commerce, Great Lakes routes, short-sea transportation, and noncontiguous domestic trade. Noncontiguous trade generally meant routes connecting the contiguous 48 states to Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, or similar noncontiguous territories. Operators running those routes had a path into the program. Most passenger vessel operators did not. A sightseeing operator in California, a dinner cruise company on the Gulf Coast, a harbor water taxi, a river operator, or a commuter ferry running between two points in the contiguous United States could be locked out entirely, regardless of how capital-intensive the operation was or how clearly it fit the spirit of the program. For operators already working in Alaska or Hawai‘i, the 2022 NDAA was less a new eligibility event than a simpli- fication. They already had a path in. What changed was the compliance burden. Proving qualification under the old noncontiguous trade rules became less central, and eligibil- ity narrowed to three clear tests: U.S.-built vessel, U.S.-flag operation, and qualified commerce. HOW IT WORKS IN PRACTICE Eligible income sources include operating revenue, vessel de- preciation recapture, and gains from vessel sales. Funds can remain in a CCF account for up to 25 years from the year of deposit. Qualified withdrawals cover new construction, reconstruction exceeding $1 million in capitalized costs, ac- quisition of vessels for eligible trades, and principal debt re- tirement tied to qualified vessel construction. Non-qualified withdrawals are treated as ordinary income and may trigger FOGHORN FOCUS When the operator later withdraws the money for a qualified purpose, the withdrawal does not create a taxable event. It reduces the tax basis of the new vessel, spreading the tax impact over the life of the asset.
View this content as a flipbook by clicking here.